On the other hand, an opposing editorial by former U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) Chair Michael LeFevre noted that “only 40 to 55 percent of children with elevated cholesterol and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) levels will continue to have elevated lipids on follow-up,” reviewed limitations in the evidence base for screening and treatment, and cautioned physicians against “caus[ing] unintended negative consequences in our zeal to prevent far-off disease.”
In 2012, an AFP Journal Club piece analyzed an article contrasting the USPSTF’s call for more research on childhood lipid screening to an American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP)-endorsed guideline, which suggested checking lipid levels in all children around age 10. Dr. Andrea Darby-Stewart and colleagues favored the USPSTF’s “more rigorous, albeit conservative” position over the AAP’s:
There is no evidence that early identification of hyperlipidemia in children changes long-term outcomes. Let’s focus our limited health care resources where they may do some good: encouraging physical activity and maintaining an appropriate body weight.
The 2019 article, Right Care for Children: Top Five Do’s and Don’ts by Dr. Matthew Schefft and colleagues, revisited the controversial topic and listed routine hyperlipidemia screening in children and adolescents as an overused intervention. In a Letter to the Editor, Drs. Cezary Wojcik and Samuel Gidding disagreed and offered another justification for universal lipid screening: to detect familial hypercholesterolemia, an asymptomatic genetic condition that affects 1 out of every 250 children and leads to premature coronary artery disease.
In the September 2024 issue of AFP, the USPSTF reaffirmed its previous statements that the evidence is insufficient to determine the balance of benefits and harms for screening for lipid disorders in asymptomatic persons 20 years or younger. A Putting Prevention into Practice case study applied the USPSTF’s statement to a common clinical scenario. Finally, an editorial by Dr. Brian Reamy proposed selectively screening for familial hypercholesterolemia with a lipid profile "for all family members older than 9 years who have a first-degree relative with a premature ASCVD event or a relative receiving treatment for LDL cholesterol greater than 190 mg per dL."
Currently, cholesterol screening in children is uncommon. A US electronic medical record study of more than 3.2 million children found that among 9 to 11 year olds, only 9% had a previous lipid profile, rising to 13% in the 17- to 21-year-old group. Although prospective cohort studies have found associations between childhood risk factors and adult cardiovascular events, the value of a lipid profile as a risk factor was called into question by a recent analysis of seven cohorts in the United States, Australia, and Finland (n = 11,500). A multivariable model derived from the data used age, sex, blood pressure, body mass index, and smoking status to predict adult cardiovascular events. Adding lipid measurements to the model did not improve risk prediction.
**
This post first appeared on the AFP Community Blog.
